Company Of The Cauldron - NANTUCKET

The best restaurant in Nuntucket. Best Romantic, Best Delicious Food, Best location, Best wine selection, Best Chef Joseph Keller, Best atmosphere, Best service. Overall the best in Massachusetts!!!

Amazing hidden gem. Well crafted food using local ingredients presented with precision and beauty. Prefix meal style allows one's pallet to wander whimsically to various regions of tastes otherwise unknown. Attentive and conscientious staff take care of everything and do so with a smile and finesse. An absolute must try restaurant! My family I attended the Thanksgiving dinner and the owners and staff are kind enough to donate all proceeds from the night to charitable causes such as feeding the hungry as well as the wounded warriors project, all the more reason to love this place! Quintessential Nantucket themes pervade the atmosphere in the room; eat well, live well, and lend a helping hand when you're able.

Always a treat. Great food and service. Thanks to the Chef and the rest of the staff.

Yesterday at night was awesome the food was wonderful!!!

My husband and I had the honor of dining at the Company of the Cauldron on our 41st wedding anniversary Nantucket trip not once, but THREE Nights in a row!!! We could not help ourselves! Every night was more special and delicious than the previous night. WOW, Three out of three home runs! We have never experienced this before in dining out. These special evening were our favorite part of our 4 day trip!!! I think we are now classified as Foodies ! Every single thing was perfect! The meals and the combinations including wine and wine pairing were off the charts, the presentation (incredible), the portions (perfect), the food was DELICIOUS, the candle light gave the perfect ambiance to our dining experience, the reservation system (helpful no waiting) and text reminders (simple), and the little extra 's like the china, the vintage pepper grinder and salt cellars. We Loved it ALL!!!! Joseph Keller and the Company staff went above and beyond, not just for us but for everyone dining. We felt so special and could see everyone was feeling their experience was too. We watched nightly how each person/group received a special word or touch from Chef Joseph. Couples were already making reservations for the holidays. Oh how we wish that included us too! How wonderful it would be to enjoy this experience in the midst of the holiday setting! We will go back to Nantucket again, just to visit the Company!!!! Thank you from the bottom of our full hearts, Joseph Keller and Company!