Old Town Pizza Co - Naperville

I didn't like their Sicilian pizza... got pepperoni couldn't taste it through the rest of it. There wasn't a balance between toppings and cheese. Maybe we could of added more toppings but we have done this before and never has been an issue. I also hadthe beer nuggets (didn't taste like anything) the outside of them were nice and toasty, but the sauce taste like water and notthick enough to dip the nuggets in. I'm a fattie, can't remember when was the last time I was disappointed about pizza. ????

Pizza is soooo good ....thin crust .. ordered it well done...perfect crispy crust doesn't flop over, can hold it with two fingers. ... browned cheese...even tastes healthy...no guilt...I ordered a large but extra large may be necessary because it'ssoo good..

I passed by this restaurant and decided to pick up a pizza for our family dinner on Friday. I'm so glad I did! The thin crust veggie pizza was fantastic, with a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. I would definitely return here!

The pizza was amazing! The service was exceptional! This place has become our family's go-to spot and will remain so. Their Chicago-style pizza is simply outstanding.

Original Review: I ordered an XL deep-dish pizza with spinach. Unfortunately, it had very little pizza sauce and way too much cheese. I noticed other customers had similar complaints about the excessive cheese and insufficient sauce. I'm relieved to know I wasn't alone in this observation. I ended up having to add my own sauce to make it somewhat enjoyable. Overall, I was quite disappointed, though the crust was the only redeeming quality.