Carmela's Pizzeria - New Carlisle

The service was great, the food was fresh and delicious and I will be going back many more times

We grabbed lunch. The 1 piece fish chips was enormous. I had the half sub combo. It was good filling.

Got overcharged because my server didn't bother to listen to what I ordered. They don't allow you to add a topping to the pizza special but when I ordered the 2 topping pizza special and said I wanted to add a topping, I was not told I could not do that. I guess I should have looked at my bill before I gave her my card. The pizza was good but the waitress was not so great when I questioned her. The table next to me just ordered a pizza special with two substitutions and she did not say a word to them. So why is one ok and not the other?

They were mid renovation...no issues make it better!!! Good service!

I ordered the first ever roast beef sub and the cook did an amazing job, for not knowing what was on it. Food and service is always great