Barrow Street Alehouse - New York

We had a reservation for a party of 8. Despite the restaurant being full (Saturday football match night), our table was ready for us upon arrival. The waitress and manager were attentive and provided excellent service throughout the meal. At the end of the night, they split the bill evenly among 4 credit cards (4 couples).

Open Table made a reservation for 10. The salon has no table for 10, so we were in 2 separate cabins. Not what we wanted. The food, while good inexpensive, was remarkable for its fatness and it did not seem to decide what was ordered. Only one person, he ordered the chili, was happy with the meal.

They didn't want to honor the reservation because they said they wouldn't keep the table that night. They forget to stop their open table account for this night due to the NCAA tournament. Luckily we could get a table another hour later.

We had a reservation for eight people. Despite the restaurant being busy due to a Saturday football game night, our booth was ready for us. Both the waitress and manager were accommodating and ensured we had everything we needed. At the end of the evening, they split the bill evenly among four credit cards for the four couples dining together.

Our reservation for 10 through Open Table resulted in us being seated in two separate booths at the restaurant. Despite the reasonable prices, we found the food to be quite greasy regardless of what was ordered. Only one person in our group was satisfied with their meal, particularly the individual who ordered the chili.