One if by Land, Two if by Sea - Beoordelingen

Always a delicious and beautiful experience! A beautiful and excellent restaurant!

The risotto was bland, bang for buck is a little questionable. Duck breast was fantastic, Desserts were great, Beef W. was spot on

Amazing place, food was wonderful, service was excellent.

Enjoying a weekend without children for the first time in years, my wife and I came to One If by Land, Two If by Sea and not sure that we have this dinner exper...

The most romantic place in the city. Cosy atmosphere, quite setting, very friendly servers. Meals are delicious. Great place to go on your own or for a date.

This is truly the most romantic restaurant in New York. And the consistency of the quality of service is across the board with all staff. We were treated extra...

Drinks were good, for the meals, soup was ok, appetizers..octopus was too tough, probably overcooked, tuna tartare was ok, for entrees, the scallops were excell...

The restaurant offers excellent food and outstanding service in a charming atmosphere that creates a truly romantic ambiance.

The atmosphere at this restaurant is fantastic, and the dishes are incredibly delicious. It has quickly become one of my top restaurant choices in all of New Yo...

We had an amazing experience for a 50th birthday dinner, especially because the staff went above and beyond to make it special after a reservation mistake. The...

The restaurant truly earns its reputation as one of the top romantic eateries in the world. Beautifully decorated, historical and charming.... very relaxing pla...

The food was spectacular melt in your mouth Wellington the service was right on point and from the moment we walked in, we were treated like valued guests. We w...

Amazing restaurant and super evening! The food and staff were first class, and the owner Maria was so lovely, made us feel at home on a very special evening. I...

What a wonderful experience for my wife and I. The food, service and surroundings were spectacular. Would recommend it to anyone.

What an awesome place to celebrate a special occasion. I celebrated my 10th wedding anniversary. The staff was friendly and the food couldn't be any better.

I went here with friends to celebrate my partner's promotion. The food was delicious. The service was acceptable but not exceptional, which is what I expected f...

The food was absolutely spectacular, very considered and very high quality. Ambience was extremely cosy and classic without being too pretentious. Service was f...

Service was extremely poor. Said three times food would be out shortly. It wasn't. Apologized by offering us some cheap wine after we had purchased a fairly exp...

Boyfriend took me here for my birthday. The whole thing was disappointing. Ahead of time he asked that we be seated overlooking the garden downstairs. We were s...

Was so incredibly disappointed. We travelled from Australia to spend Christmas 2023 in New York. What better way than to spend Christmas dinner at one of the mo...

The tasting menu with the wine pairing is fantastic! Excellent service and loved the ambience. The live piano playing was really nice.

Exceptional service with amazing food. Some of the best food I have had in NY. You are going to spend more here but you will not be disappointed. Live piano was...

My partner and I had a wonderful experience celebrating our anniversary. The double espresso was a nice final touch on a wonderful evening. We did have a billin...

Always a staple for us that never disappoints! I branched out from my typical martini order and ordered the Two of by sea a Prosecco and lillet cocktail and was...

Beautiful restaurant. Several fireplaces and separate eating areas to provide San intimate dining experience. Cocktails are great but the food is mediocre and t...

What a beautiful restaurant. They had a piano player when I dined here which really added to the experience. Our server was extremely knowledgeable and helpful...

This is very sophisticated high end place with the history that goes back to 18th century. Perfect for romantic dinner or date night. To be honest I was there f...

Had an absolutely lovely evening celebrating an anniversary here. The live piano player is an elegant touch. The food was sensational, the service impeccable (t...

Our experience was top notch in every regard. The setting and ambiance are very romantic and rustic, and each course was perfectly executed. The cuisine was tra...

Beautiful and unique space, which is ideal for dates. The food was good, but a bit expensive. The Beef Wellington is the best I've had in the city. Only the Val...

Amazing service! Our server, Nick, was wonderful and checked up on us after every dish. Great lighting and decorations as well. I highly recommend!

I went to this restaurant 2 times so far. The restaurant is very cozy and charming and the history behind it is quite intriguing. I loved the live piano...

Came here for a holiday prix fixe it was one of the most underwhelming and overpriced dining experiences we've had in New York (and we've lived here for...