Village Square Pizza - New York City

After taking a few months to move on, I was finally ready to seek out a new late-night pizza spot after a few unsuccessful attempts at the local bars. On Saturday, after our bar-hopping, my friend suggested this place, claiming it was similar to Prince Street Pizza. As we entered, we encountered a small line and were greeted by not just one, but two bright neon signs. I love a good neon sign. The staff was incredibly efficient, operating like a well-oiled machine. I decided to get two slices of the thick square pizza, topped with those adorable, slightly charred pepperonis. The total came to $11.98 for both slices—an amazing deal! I think this place might even be better than Prince Street. If not, it’s definitely in the same league. The crust was perfectly crisp, and those pepperonis were out of this world—truly top-notch. After finishing my first slice, I thought to myself, “Wow, I probably could have been satisfied with just one slice…” I guess I’m still a little traumatized from my experience with East Village Pizza. I've found my new go-to late-night pizza spot. Before I sign off, I want to leave you with a quote from Marilyn Monroe: “Sometimes good things fall apart so better things can fall together.” Follow me on Instagram @jnov_Tiktok @jnov_!

Village Square Pizza is my favorite place for square slices in NYC. There are no long lines, the hot honey is fantastic, and the pepperoni cups are a delight. It doesn’t get better than this!

One of the best Sicilian-style pizzas I've ever had! The sauce is packed with flavor, and the crust is wonderfully crispy. The pizza isn’t greasy or oily at all. They offer a wide range of both vegetarian and non-vegetarian options to choose from. You can eat at the narrow counter inside, and the service is quick!

Try the grandma slice and the Sicilian slice very very good pizza. This is your small pizza takeout shop with no washroom

Enjoyed a delicious slice of original New York-style pizza at Village Square Pizza. The pizza was tasty, unique, and the service was commendable. A great place for pizza lovers – definitely recommended. Solid 4 stars.