Wally's Bagels - North Babylon

My bagels are always fresh and tasty. I went there late on a Fri and the server yt-grl) was very rude when I asked a question BUT! I went back on Sat and the young man with the clean haircut was on point and very nice and professional. I really appreciate the fact that he made my bagel the way I wanted and knew the names of all types of bagels in the store. Thank you sir!

The bagels are not that good they are dry and flavorless. They put way to much cream cheese and no love into the service. My bagels had hardly any butter as well on the plain one and were like eating paper. Egg sandwiches are scarce with ingredients. Hype for nothing honestly. Not even cut all the way through. Just a mess and waste of money. Really should care more about quality and service verses quantity of customers

Best bagels on Long Island hands down. They’re huge bagels also. My job buys bagels every Friday for us and they come from Wally’s and I have to say I have never had better bagels before. I’d definitely recommend!

First visit to Wally’s bagels. For a time the best bagels that I had eaten were in NYC, but Wally’s proved that they have competition. Bagels very soft and tasty. Staff was pleasant. Short wait even though many customers. Overall great experience. Will buy from them again.

Been coming here on and off for years and the food is always great. Best bagels in the world. Even when the line is long, orders are quick. The last 2 times I’ve been in I’ve been waited on by Steve and he is awesome. So friendly and kind and I absolutely love the way he takes just a few extra seconds to make sure he has my order right. That guy is a gem.