Fratelli's Pizzeria - Olde West Chester

I'm a bit conflicted with this place. Had an amazing Lg pie the 1st time with a gentleman on a weekday. I fell inlove with the place. 2nd time got medium pie with a lady it went down hill on a weekend. The crust just wasn't the same it was ruined. Gave it another chance on a weekend since I have visitor from out of town. Ordered Lg pie again this time. The same lady appears to be working still off. So dissapointed wish it'd be consistent as the 1st time trying this.

I have been to pizza restaurants all over the Cincinnati area. I keep going back to Fratellis. They are by far the best choice for pizza around. I have had other dishes from them as well and am always happy with the food. Their staff is always polite and helpful. I usually don't do reviews like this but felt it was finally time to for them.

I grew up in New Jersey and this pizza is one of the very few in the area that reminds me of how pizza should be.

The pizza was delicious and the staff very friendly. The closest to ny/nj pizza that I’ve found in the area.

Great pizza and very good garlic knots. Most authentic New York style pizza in the area.