Amici’s Pizza - Peekskill

My new construction project just started next to here. I got their chicken Parm and pepperoni pizza and tastes great! Been going there multiple times by now and won’t be going anywhere else for the time being. Would probably be gaining a few pounds after a while, but who cares the food taste great! Sincerely, Atrin H

This restaurant has recently been taken over by new owners and we have been patrons of Amicis for the last 12 years. It was always very good but the new owners have stepped it up and the food is really delicious along with great service. I would highly recommend Amicis. Their pizza is also one of the best around. The prices are also very reasonable.

Very good Italian food. It's a little to cold inside. They should regulate the temperature, sometimes.

New owners and a definite plus. Fine before, excellent now. Warm friendly atmosphere, everything we’ve tried has been delicious, we’ll be back to try more. I hear the tiramisu is worth a trip. Pies are pretty good too

So I ordered delivery from here and was so-so. I ordered spaghetti meatballs, chicken francese and a side of broccoli rabe. The spaghetti meatball was pretty decent the sauce needs a little salt but overall a solid 7 on the classic dish. But the chicken francese was terrible. The chicken wasn't soft and it wasn't lemony zest just all butter or margarine. The broccoli rabe was the worst, it wasn't cooked enough to where the garlic tasted raw. I later recooked the rabe and it tasted good but this shouldn't be the case when you pay $10 for a side. I hate giving 3 stars so I would eat here again to confirm the score. 60/100