Annabella's Pizza Pasta - Peekskill

Annabella’s Pizza Pasta is a must visit when in the Peekskill area! My family wasn’t disappointed! Pizza is crispy and authentic, bursting with flavor. Staff were very kind and accommodating. Not to mention the reasonable prices. Great location, lots of fun on the weekends with outdoor seating and live music. The establishment itself sits on a main road with many shops and restaurants! This shop is perfect to eat out with family or wanting to spend some time outdoors.

They used to be good before they reopened. The food isn't the same quality any more, and either comes burnt or undercooked. Won't be coming here any longer.

Amazing true Italian pizza and delicious wings! highly recommended! very nice place and professional nice cook!

Consider this just a quick review of the plain slice. I got a wide, cheesy, somewhat floppy and greasy, undercooked slice. It's not a crispy or crunchy crust, it has a softer chew. And I'd say it's on the paler side of brown in the bake. It's definitely a raw sauce cooked on the pie, not pre-simmered. The sauce is unadulterated ground tomato without like lightly seasoned with just salt. I don't detect oregano or basil. If you really like more mozzarella, soft crust and less sauce, this will be up your alley.

I love this place. The food is amazing it's always fresh the portions are definitely worth the price. I always order too much and end up taking some home with me, good thing is their food is just as good the 2nd time around. I'll swing by here 3 to 4 times a month. I'd recommend the pizza rolls and the soup is great as well.