Old Town Pizza - Port Jefferson Station

We order from Old Town all the time. We love the stuffed rigatoni and the grilled chicken salad. I could go on and on about the food, we have honestly never had an anything bad. pizza slices are amazing.

They sent me a ceaser salad but i ordered a grilled Chicken Salads (Large) even though the order was wrong i still enjoyed it. food is fresh and fantastic

Old town always fulfills every specific food instruction!

I love this pizza! healthy but delicious option!!! I'm hooked!!!

The service was reprehensible. I ordered a Caprese salad and they substituted a totally different salad without giving us proper notice. The salad they substituted was a burrata salad without any cheese, which is the reason I'm assuming I didn't receive a Caprese salad to begin with. That's annoying but understandable. However when we called to see if we could get something else more to my taste, the man was incredibly rude and then hung up on us mid-word, which is entirely unacceptable. Do better.