Brooklyn Joe's - Punta Gorda

This restaurant is absolutely fantastic! I stumbled upon it after watching a YouTube short they made. The Sicilian pizza is amazing, and the tiramisu is incredibly delicious! I highly recommend you give this place a try.

We ordered The Works Pizza and picked it up hot since we live nearby. Unfortunately, it had very few toppings, and the crust was thin and mushy. Our appetizers were just as disappointing—bland and overpriced! I've noticed that any honest one or two-star reviews receive rude responses from this business. MY REVIEW STANDS!

I picked up my daughter from Punta Gorda airport this afternoon. Before she left Nashville, she mentioned she was hungry and wanted pizza. I looked up local pizza places and after reading a few reviews, decided on Brooklyn Joe's, and it was the perfect choice! We got a large pepperoni pizza, which was wonderfully foldable for the drive home. I took some extra napkins because I had read one comment about the pizza being greasy, but that wasn’t the case at all! The only thing that barely leaked onto the napkin was a tiny drop of pepperoni juice. The crust was just right! I'm so glad I stopped by and will definitely return next time I'm in the area. The service was excellent, too!

A hidden gem in Punta Gorda. By far the best pizza we have tasted here in FL! That’s including reviews from our 5 kids, and a husband who doesn’t like pizza … Favorites of the day were the Buffalo Chicken and the White … Although the kids would argue that the Cheese pizza is best. If you’re out this way, this should be a definite stop. The servers were amazing, incredibly friendly and hospitable. The restaurant is clean and well kept.

Absolutely delicious vegan pizza on cauliflower crust! Thanks for offering it! Not enough options in Punta Gorda for alternative diets.