Pauly's Cafe - Saint Marys

The ribeye steak is incredible! The service is exceptional as well. A fantastic spot for locals to gather.

I used to visit Pauly's at St Mary's but found it open today after it being closed during my last two attempts. I sat at the tiki bar as usual, but it looked messy and neglected since hurricane Matthew struck in 2016. After having three beers, I left feeling very disappointed.

This restaurant is dirty, has slow service, serves warm soda, has bugs, unfriendly staff, and left us waiting for long periods of time. There were stains on our plates.

Stopped Sunday to try for the first time. Closed! Sign and Webb site stated 11:00 am opening time. We were there at 11:15. Menu looks good, disappointed could not try the food. I know it's hard to keep a business open but keeping your hours updated goes along way in gaining customers. We drove almost 45 mins. to only be disappointed.

Staff is very friendly and prompt great overall experience