Sibby's Cupcakery - San Mateo

The cupcakes are absolutely amazing! Each one is delicious. Sibby and her team are fantastic!

The cupcakes were absolutely delicious! I picked up a dozen mixed flavors for a girls' night I was hosting. I arrived at Sibby's around 12:15, and unfortunately, many of the flavors were already sold out (which is why I'm giving four stars). They were also a bit on the pricey side (hence another four stars), but the taste made it worth it. I definitely plan to return, but I’ll make sure to go earlier next time.

What’s even more impressive is that this place is nut-free, which is essential for my daughter who has a life-threatening peanut allergy. Plus, they offer gluten-free options for my stepdaughter! I tried the raspberry lemon cupcake, and it was not only beautifully decorated but also perfectly sweet and bursting with flavor. I’ll definitely be returning to explore more flavors. The best part? There’s no need to pre-order! With so many flavors available, I could easily grab a few dozen on the fly for a last-minute gathering.

I called in an order on Friday for a pickup order the next day, and the person who assisted me was super helpful and understanding. I ordered a dozen gluten free assorted flavored cupcakes for my uncle's birthday. He said they tasted like regular cupcakes! I personally couldn't tell the difference either. For anyone who's gluten free, I highly recommend!

Still 5 stars two years later! Sibby's did our wedding cupcakes and they were so easy to work with. The cupcakes were delicious! I was so happy to have ordered more than we needed because we ate them for another few days after. They were still good and moist after days!!