Carrina's Pizzeria - Sarasota

Wow! We had the Cheesesteak Sub and was the BEST in the area by far!! We also had a calzone and it was THE BEST I had everywhere. I spoke to the owner and he says he uses fresh shaved ribeye and fresh vegetables and makes his bread fresh daily! I'm a very picky eater and my wife is a boss and I'm hard to impress! This is my new place for Subs, Calzones and Pizza!!! Must try!! I found this place by chance when I went to Gentile Bros next door, but they were from Provolone cheese! Find amazing! This is an honest assessment of a surprise visit today. Don't hesitate! Better than Solorzanos too! Wow.

I discovered Palermo's pizza today with luck as I stay close. I'm from Philly, so my standards are high. It is individually owned and meals are made with high-quality ingredients. I had a highest pizza. The owner hand scolds the crust and makes the incredible marinara sauce. All right! Many choices for vegan and gluten-free also. When I picked up the pizza, he gave me about 10 samples of AMAZING's homemade ice cream. Both standard and unique delicious varieties. It uses all natural ingredients. I don't even know how it could taste so good!! It was hard to get desert (that I didn't plan on food!

Locked in for a pizza search. Came home with an AMAZING Spinat Feta Pizza, Italian ice cream, and my daughters each got a pint of homemade ice cream. The owner was very nice and offered us a tasting of every ice cream while we waited for our pizza. Can't wait to come back and try more from the menu.

That's a great place where we stumble. Pizza was great, the crust was amazing with a great sauce! Our waitress Delaney was great! Pete the owner was so cool and great with our children. Will definitely visit us again. The homemade ice cream was killer!

This local family-owned and operated restaurant was recommended to me by a good friend. I took my wife and two daughters to the restaurant on a Saturday night. We were greeted with a smile and were sitting at a table quickly. If you’d like real authentic pizza, made with fresh ingredients with the dough made on site by hand, this is the place for you. My daughters are very particular about their pizza and they absolutely loved the pizza. As for me, I’m a big cheesesteak fan and I was not disappointed. The bread is made fresh every day on site. The cheesesteak is made fresh with lots of meat and was absolutely delicious. My wife is a big meatball sub fan and she fell in love with this one. We had such a great time we decided to try the Italian ice and handmade ice cream. Both were excellent. We will be back in soon, and will become regulars, for certain. We were very enamored with this restaurant and the staff; it was a terrific experience all around.