Mixed Fillings Pie Shop - Sharpes

The best key lime pie I have ever had! The chocolate brownie pie (not the correct name) was amazing as well. Run to get your pies here! So delicious!

The coconut cream pie is the best I've ever had! We bought a pie flight (4 slices) for $25. The others were peach/blackberry crumble, strawberry lemon, and French silk. All were delicious and worth the price.

This place lives up to the hype. I had a slice of the peanut butter pie the first time around and it's one of the best things I've ever tasted in my life. Certainly the best pie I've ever had! Today I had the chicken pot pie, we've been looking for a good one here for ages. Let me tell you... that pie was heavenly. You can feel the love in the food radiating through your body when you eat it. On top of all that, the owner is really nice and the decor inside is top notch. The kitchen is clean, if you peek into the back you can see that this is a place where people care about things. You could eat off of the floor in there! Top notch experience, highly recommended!

This pie is amazing! We drove over 2 hours and would gladly make the trip again. The slices on the pie flights are very generous and everything we tried was excellent. We especially liked the key lime and lemon lavender. Looking forward to the next trip.

Kudos to this pastry chef bec these pies are on point! I didn’t even know I was a pie person until today! Even their breakfast bacon quiche was so yummmm! I Iove that they sell pie by a slice so you can sample different ones before committing to a whole pie. We sampled 9 and all were great but the quiche, pecan, and key lime were our top 3!