Faye's Pizza, LLC - Sheboygan

Well, Googled Pizza, went to little ol Faye’s while passing through. Never have I had more cheese on a pizza. Deep dish supreme minus anchovies with xtra cheese. Pizza pie came out!!! I’m delightfully stuffed…. 2 guys couldn’t finish this 12 inch medium. Thick? YES! Tasty? Double yes!!

First time we stopped at Faye's and I loved the pizza. The manager on duty was very friendly and I was delighted when I saw him take time to thank an elderly Marine that came in after us. Our server was very shy and not so attentive, but we surmized she may have been new and cut her some slack. Would not hesitate to return to Faye's.

Picked up some frozen pizzas but haven't tried them yet. Waited in car until they opened at 4:00pm. Other customers that I walked in with and were planning on dining in, had to ask to have their table cleaned first. They were never wiped down from the night before. That's the only reason for a four star.

Faye's Pizza definitely has the best Hawaiian Pizza in Sheboygan, WI!! We usually have our cheese pizza delivered, but we ate there today and enjoyed it greatly! We love the crispy thin crusts and yummy cheese they have on their pizzas!!

This is a nice little place to eat in, order to go or delivered. I was impressed and satisfied. Stopped in while on a business trip. The pizza was hot, delicious and very filling. Good service and great staff and very well priced.