Godfather's Pizza Express - Shelby

Garlic bread with cheese and veggie pizza thanks #godfather #pizza #shelby #Iowa Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Parking options: Free parking lot

The staff was nice and the place seemed clean but the pizza was disappointing. We tried to order a small but they only had mini or large so we got a large. We wanted thick crust but they only offered pan style. It looked ok if a little heavy on the cheese but it was terribly greasy from said cheese and the crust tasted like it had been rubbed heavily with butter right before being baked. The veggies and everything were fine but as soon as I got 3 bites in I wanted to puke. My husband has an iron stomach and even he barely finished a slice before getting sick. We both ate 1 piece each to survive the next few hours to the next town but we deeply regretted ever ordering that pizza. It was $20 and we literally threw the entire large pizza minus the 2 slices in the trash. It took us both about 2 days to fully recover from the nausea and it was very difficult to eat anything besides bland foods in that time. If you are used to greasy, buttery foods then give it a shot because it had potential, we just are NOT used to that. We didn't take pictures because like I said, it looked like a decent pizza and ended up tossing it in the trash 10min later. I didn't see a point in asking for our money back since we were passing through and in a hurry but I kind of wish I had since it was so expensive.

Apparently their phone doesn't work. Called 3 times let it ring until the call ended. Didn't get a pizza since I don't want to stand there and wait for it. would have preferred to order ahead of time and pick up.

It's usually pretty decent. Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

Service: Take out Price per person: $1–10 Recommended dishes: Breadsticks, Classic Combo