Feelin' Saucy Pizzeria - Sherman

Absolutely love the place. Pizza was the best I had in years. Wings were great but pricey compared to neighboring places. Staff were friendly. I definitely recommend checking this place out if you like the way things were before the 20th century, it's just got a good vibe and the food reminds you of a simpler and better point in time.

I was ready to spend $60 on pizza and wings while fishing on Chautauqua Lake in New York. This was the only shop that could deliver to Mayville, but it's disappointing that in 2022 they still don't have a card payment system set up.

Absolutely delicious! The very best pizza and wings in town. This quaint, humble place will not disappoint! They are serious about their food, and their service. No mistakes about it, everything I've ever ordered here over the years has been amazing. Definitely recommend!

We stopped by looking for a place to eat. The staff are extremely friendly and the food was outstanding. Very reasonable as well. We will definitely be coming back!

First time there and pleasantly surprised. Pizza and wings very good. Price very reasonable. Similar tasting pizza sauce as Lena's in Jamestown for those who know or have been too