Bagel Pantry - South Plainfield

Visiting the area; like to make a stop here for the bagels as it’s delicious, love the smell of the bagels. Ordered a bagel sandwich for breakfast with an iced latte very satisfied. Staff was friendly.

I live in PA now and have not had a decent bagel in YEARS!! They were excellent! I will drive the three hours to get them again!!

Great bagels, but!, it's not often the staff follows directions. Last Saturday morning I placed an order for pick-up the next day, late Sunday morning. When I went to get it, it wasn't ready ... no one even started it. I was pressed for time ... and had to wait. I asked why it wasn't ready and all I got was a blank stare. And lately they aren't following directions on what I order.

Quality is barely average sometimes you get a bagel with enough cream cheese sometimes you don’t and you only get napkins if you ask for some reason. And can you turn the heat on? It’s freezing in there just barely average I don’t know what happened to this place

I'm definitely disappointed with this place. I ordered 2 bagels, toasted with butter. Can't get any easier than that. Right? Wrong!!! Obviously the bagel is definitely not toasted properly and I have a slab of butter on each of my bagels. Simply horrible. And of course I am working and on the road. So I can't turn around and get a new order but with that being said. If it was done right the 1st time, then I shouldn't have to go back. Anyway, STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE. You've been warned