Pizza Pantry Spencer

Horrible experience. I am a vegetarian and they gave me meat and would not help or replace it! It was not at all what I ordered. It was 25$ wasted!Went into store to ask to make it right. Got soda thrown on my shoe, and intimidated. So much for a good hometown place where people look out for each other. Terrible disrespect, worst customer service I have ever had. I've never even left a bad review until this place!

Delicious! The outside wasn't exciting but not many choices in Spencer, so we went inside for pizza. Just delicious! I'm so glad we ate here. The inside was fun and clean. The dough and pizza were mouth watering. Next time we camp near here we will return.

Pizza was burnt, called to tell them and the girl tried to tell me that's the way their pizza are then they was having trouble with the oven. No Manger to talk to said would call but no call.will never go back for trashy pizza.

I live an hour away in Bargersville. I will gladly drive here for my pizza cravings. You don’t get this quality in Greenwood. The food is unbelievable. The pepperoni pie is easily way better than the major chains. 5/5 stars. The staff is amazing. New ownership really turned this joint around. I just ate here on a Friday and am considering making the drive on Saturday to get more.

The “new” pizza isn’t bad, but it’s NOTHING like it was. The sauce doesn’t have any flavor, the crust is different, and the meats aren’t the same. We used to drive back to Spencer especially for a Pizza Pantry pie, but this isn’t it!