Blackfly St Augustine - St. Augustine

We had a wonderful anniversary dinner at Blackfly. I had the lobster and my husband had the Triggerfish. Both were cooked perfectly. The owner was on hand and stopped by the table 3 times to make sure all was to our satisfaction. They even threw in a complimentary slice of margarita pie which was wonderful. Our server was excellent as well. They are very busy so get a reservation. We will definitely be back if we head back this way.

Great food Great service Great atmosphere Great location

Love Blackfly. Always try to stop in when we are in town. Last visit (Aug 2023) we chatted with Vaughn about his new art series. We will be back soon.

We thought we would try a new place close to the City of St Augustine and was pleasantly surprised. On-site parking, a bar area with casual dining and an eclectic area for dining. Our server was friendly and attentive and the food was creative and tasty!

Firstly, the vibe in the restaurant was good. Unfortunately after that things went downhill. Drinks were missed, the wrong order taken, cold mash and just a little bit underwhelming. Drinks were ok but overpriced. To be fair I think was one of the servers first nights so everyone has to learn. Out of all my restaurant experiences in St Augustine unfortunately this one goes down as “not again”