Your Pie - St. Augustine

Easily one of my favorite places to eat after moving here to St Augustine, always such friendly staff and excellent food.

My kids and I love this place, it’s our favorite pizza around the World Gulf/Palencia area the staff is great too. The birthday cake gelato is so good.I had the Great White, hubby had a pepperoni, kids had a cheese, all of our pizzas were good.

We 've been customers since LOCATION 1st opened; I know for sure changed hands 2x; possible 3 (regardless) recent new ownership/management staff are the BEST!! We had stopped going for a time due to several reasons. We are/will now be BACK weekly either dine in or take home. SINCE our return last few weeks; one was take home 2 were dine in. Take home or delivery (I think they use Uber We 've not done that) EVERTHING has been truly Your way Perfect! If you 've not tried I suggest you do an if you 've not been back I highly recommend you give new chance. While I rated atmosphere as 5 that strictly due to this particular venue; counter order, so don 't expect to be tabled waited on. And while neither my husband or I used restroom, the place is CLEAN! they have happy beer days and really good Gelato! So, even if you don 't want pizza this month they have a Pumpkin Gelato that is fabulous! Your wine or beer choice can be packed for take home, if you don 't want to dine in. Also, felt I needed to add both my husband I order separate pizzas, sometimes we get adult beverages almost always get Gelato, that 's why I rated as I did.Vegetarian options: They accommodate and have as many, if not more Vegetarian options and also a number of Vegan optionsDietary restrictions: They have options for ALL dietary desires; however if you 've severe allergy issues you would need to advise PRIOR to order so they can properly ensure separation.Parking: While in a strip mall there 's always parking.

Apparently Your Pie is now under new management and the pizza and service was excellent, not at all like my experience 4 years ago. It will become my goto local pizza shop. Well done !

I had the Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza and it was simply amazing, the service was great and love the atmosphere! Keep up the great work!