Day One Pizza - Sun Prairie

We were searching for a place to eat in Sun Prairie on a Saturday night without a reservation. After trying two other places that were completely full, we were about to head home when we stumbled upon Day One, which was surprisingly empty. Feeling hungry and eager to try something new, we decided to give it a shot. Although the dining area wasn’t busy, they were bustling with delivery orders, and now I understand why. The service was outstanding and the food came out quickly and tasted fantastic. We ordered the Chicken Garlic Alfredo Pizza on hand-tossed crust and a side salad for three people, and it was incredibly satisfying! The pizza was delicious and bursting with flavor! We’ll definitely be coming back!

We had an amazing experience at this restaurant! The service was outstanding, and the pizza was fantastic. We visited on a Sunday afternoon, and David graciously gave our family of four a tour of the kitchen, which the kids absolutely loved. The staff is incredibly friendly and genuinely focused on customer service. The kids ordered the Mac-N-Cheese pizza, while we tried the sharp Italian—both were delicious! My children declared it the best Mac-N-Cheese pizza they’ve ever had! We're a bit disappointed that they don't deliver to our city, but we will definitely return to the restaurant. We highly recommend this place!

Delicious pizza! The staff is always so warm and welcoming to my wife and me. We recently moved to North Carolina but made it a point to stop by for the best pizza when we visited Wisconsin.

Hands down is one of the best pizza places in town. Your crusts are perfect doughy and taste great. Their ingredients are fresh and quite generously applied. You have some pretty great special pizzas that my wife likes the Speck Cheeseburger while I myself am a Taco type. Your prices tend to be on the higher side, but do not let you taste the difference in quality safely.

Great pizza, great service. They are very the fastest to deliver my pizza, (typically within 30-35 minutes of placing my order), and the pizza is always very hot and delicious! They have a nice variety of pizzas, as well as the sizes. They even have a 10' gluten free pizza!! You can always go in a dine too, thei lobby is always very clean and classy. Day One can also prep your food for a food allergy! I definitely recommend everyone to try their pizza, you won't be disappointed!!