Gotham Provisions Co. - Sun Prairie

The bagel sandwich was delicious! I tried it for the first time and the spicy Italian sausage made it truly amazing. Highly recommend the Mid Town!

The breakfast and lunch are outstanding. You can savor the delightful local ingredients in every bite.

My wife and I enjoyed lunch at her hidden gem, Gotham, which recently opened in Sherman. We were in search of genuine deli sandwiches, and Gotham did not disappoint. The cashier suggested a hot ham and Swiss sandwich with arugula on a pumpernickel bagel, and it was fantastic. My wife opted for a pastrami and Swiss on pumpernickel as well. We will definitely be returning!

I love downtown. Both places have large bagels, sandwiches, coffee and house made spreads. The only reason I'm not 5 stars for this location is because it's very new and there are some kinks to work, especially adjust the service style and space for Sun Prairie. But I was still here several times and was never disappointed!

Got the Staten island on an egg bagel. It was a great sandwich, well made. I also ordered a NY dozen. They offered advice on how to freeze and serve the bagels later. They are NY bagels!