Millers Bakery - Tenafly

Treat yourself to a wonderful experience! I had one of the best experiences at Millers, exceeding my expectations. I ordered a custom cake for my son's 10th birthday, and they delivered exactly what I requested—complete with delivery! The cake was incredibly moist and delicious, far beyond what I had hoped for. The staff was friendly and efficient. I will definitely be ordering all my cakes from here in the future!

I came in for cookies and ended up enjoying the treats and hot cocoa! I didn’t catch the names of the two older ladies at the front counter, but they were incredibly friendly and kind. I’ll definitely be coming back!

This bakery is my go-to for special occasions. Their fruit cakes are ideal for celebrations. Both brothers moved out of state and can't find crab cakes and pecan rings like the ones we enjoyed in our childhood. I make it a priority to visit Miller's Bakery and send cakes to them throughout the year. In our opinion, Miller's Bakery offers the best crumb cake of any bakery we know. The service is always courteous, patient, and incredibly helpful.

Had made a cake for my future daughter in law shower and could not be happier! Everyone shaved how delicious the cake was so moist and the Canoli filling was perfectly not excessively sweet. I would definitely recommend that you not be disappointed!

As long-time patrons of Millers, we consistently find their baked goods to be thoughtfully crafted and absolutely delicious. Ani and Kristina, who serve at the counter during the weekdays, are always friendly and eager to assist, making our visits even more enjoyable as we chat with them. The custom cakes we’ve ordered have always been flawless. Our only regret is that Millers has removed the TVs from the corners of the dining area; having them would encourage diners to linger a bit longer at their tables.