Tootsie’s Sugar Shop

My two friends and I visited in the evening of New Years Day. The two young men working were AWESOME! There was only a few of us in the store at the same time so they were able to be extra attentive and really go above and beyond with sampling to help us make a decision for donut and ice cream flavors. The range of toppings is excellent as well, I got to try gummies I’ve never even seen before. A great experience!

Great candy, ice cream, and mini donut shop. The mini donuts are crispy, taste like fresh funnel cake already broken up into bite size pieces, really cute donuts. The taffy are soft and taste freshly made. To top it off, a young named Alex provided excellent service. The donut machine was down for a bit, he went thru the trouble to get back up to serve a batch of minis. A great way to end a nice day at the beach.

This is a place for nostalgia and great desserts. They have ice cream samples and have these made to order donuts that are the perfect size for sharing as well as portion control. Cinnamon sugar Light and fluffy but could use a bit of salt for a contrast but a very solid donut. Coconut it's a regular donut with a glaze and toasted coconut flakes. It's really good and just sweet enough to make me feel not too guilty. Ambiance nostalgic it's a great place to find those hard to find candies and the staff is awesome

Fresh tiny donuts made in front of you. Run, do not walk. And get some fantastic donuts!

Absolutely wonderful people and space ! I love coffee ice cream and they hands down have it. The coffee was THE best we have tried on the island. The doughnuts smelled amazing but that night just wanted ice cream! Be careful, when they ask if you want a bowl with your waffle cone? Take it. I did not! They fill for two scoops. Worth it.