Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street

Food is always fresh and amazing even when we do takeout.

Descent pizza, but don’t come here with a large group. Our server spoke so quietly I could barely hear him. When it came to the check, mine had to be corrected twice, because he couldn’t figure out who ordered what. Service wasn’t all that great. Pizza was just “ok”.

My fiance and I are here for a big AG teachers conference for the weekend. We came in around 5:20 Thursday evening. Got sat at our table , looked over the menu and ordered our drinks and garlic knots. Our waiter then asked what pizza we would like which we said the SPQR. One of our favorites. So he goes away we chat and eat on our garlic knots… about 20 minutes goes by and he comes up and asks again “what pizza did y’all want” kinda confused my fiancé had replied. So he goes back over to the computer types something in. And I’m saying to my fiancé think he just put our order in but I don’t know anything.. 10 or 15 more minutes ago by and he’s coming to us a with a pizza, he sets it down and rushes off before we can even say it’s not the pizza we ordered. It’s a meat filled pizza that neither me or my fiancé would eat. So after 5 minutes he finally looks at us and I’m able to get his attention- and I say this isn’t the pizza he orders and he just goes “oh, well what do you want” and I said the SPQR and he sighs and walks back to the computer. He asked a lady with short curly hair to assist in taking the other pizza off which I’m assuming is the manager at the moment. He comes back to the table and takes the other pizza still not saying a single thing. Not a “i apologize for the inconvenience” “your new pizza will be out soon” so at this moment it’s about 6:15 .. only got one refil on sodas thanks to the Togo girl who was top notch and was so kind to us. Cold garlic knots that we just had to snack on because the wait. Finally our pizza comes out at 6:30… an hour after we initially ordered. It was just a poor time- I would think after making the misted you would take great care of your table but he didn’t. He avoided us. Pizza had an odd taste we ate a slice each and didn’t even take the rest to go .

The GF pizza crust is not very good. The regular pizzas are usually pretty good but they don’t Travel well and get soggy the next day. The antipasto appetizer is delicious. Wide selection of beers. Any of the pizzas can be made on GF crust but they only come in one size (small).

It might look really cool in there, but all I really saw was the total lack of integrity in the entire staff. I went in to pick up a door dash and was told pizza would be ready in 7-8 min. I went in 13 min later only to be told the exact word for word blatten lie by another employee. Needless to say the order was extremely late. I understand busy af....I don't understand the need to lie. So disappointing for such a high profile restaurant