A.j. 's Heavenly Pizza - Upper Sandusky

Wanted a pizza while watching the Guardians vs Yankees game at my parents house. Wanted Susie's, but they were closed. Decided to try AJ's. Sadly I was disappointed. Went with a large pepperoni, mushroom, and extra cheese, it was $20. Unfortunately theredidn't seem like there was much pepperoni or mushrooms on the pizza, and I didn't care much for the sauce as it was super sweet.The service was fine. Just wasn't a fan. I'm a little spoiled by Tubbys for price, quantity, and taste.

Foods great but they never answer the phone so I just stopped calling.

Favorite place to order pizza from between marion and upper sandusky! Always good customer service and the product is always delicious.

If you offer stuffed crust pizza then you deserve a 5 star rating! I just haven't tried it yet. Lol. But i will the next time. These guys working here are the nicest people I have encountered at any business ever! They deserve the good rating theyhave.

Usually great Pizza. Have had some complaints in the past about burnt crust or missing toppings. I had been a loyal customer for probably 20 years my family has been buying pizza from AJ's Heavenly Pizza clear back when it was located in sycamore Ohio. Iwas trying to celebrate yesterday finding out that I am graduating college with honors. When I called to order my pizza which Ihad not bought one for several months. That because I had problems with my past orders and they didn't feel they could satisfyme. That the Owners decided that they could no longer take my business. I had no problems with my last two pizzas. So please ifthere is a problem with your pizza please don't issue any complaints about it, or you might find that they no longer want yourbusiness. Great way to be rejected to celebrate finding out I was Graduating college with honors. Please pray for them. And mayGod bless them. Tried to order a pizza almost 6 months to a year later was told they did not want my business. Funny how theyclaim to be a Christian business but don't actually practice christian values in my opinion.