Pizza Paul's - Village of Geneseo

Very good. The calzone was huge and really full. Everyone who had pizza in my group said the crust was great. Guy working there was friendly.

LOVE this place! Excellent food, service, and people.

Sadly this place has gone down hill. Wing sauce was really lacking... no Buffalo favor or body at all. And the sheet pizza hardly any pepperoni except for the couple pieces they dumped a pile on. This was a childhood treat that is not the same anymore!

I was told they don't take phone orders except for Saturday and Sunday. They don't offer their pizza wing combos on line . I was told over the phone how to do this , which probably took longer than it would than to have just taken my order. I hung up the phone and dialed j and t pizza where they take phone orders !!!!!!! Lost my business

What happened to the pizza I grew up on?I have consumed 100's of pizza Paul's pizzas since the late 80's. It has been a year or two since I had the chance to stop in. Stopped in today and the pizza was thick and doughy. You guys had the BEST thin crust pizza! Why did you mess with perfection?