Good Fellas Pizza - Warrenton

I conveniently timed my feedstore run with lunch. The crust and the marinara are the make or break for a pizza, calzone, Stromboli. Good Fellas Warrenton’s choice of ingredients and finesse— created a perfect combination of flavor and texture. Portions are enough to share, though I was grateful I didn’t have to share my dessert! Chocolate Mousse Cake— mmm made me chew slower out of pleasure! I am not a chef or a baker so I may get terms wrong (I’m just a foodie — it seemed to have like a thin layer of chocolate… like a ganache maybe, a dense cake that wasn’t heavy (how is that even possible?! with a very light and fluffy chocolate mousse between the layers. OMG. I will be back. The menu is extensive— I recommend checking it out before hand. I saw several other meals and desserts I look forward to trying, next visit.

I am still trying to understand why this restaurant has so many 5-star ratings. My expectations were very high, but I found the prices to be overly expensive. I could have bought 6-7 pizzas for the price of the 4 pies I purchased here. Unfortunately, I believe Domino's Pizza is better. They offer a variety of crusts and truly mean it when they say a 1-topping pizza can have any topping. I was disappointed to learn that this place advertised a 1-topping pizza special, but charged extra for any meat topping. Essentially, the special only included cheese and a vegetable topping, with sausage being an additional charge. This was my first and last visit to this restaurant. The cashier was very friendly, though - perhaps that is why they have so many 5-star ratings.

I will tell you this....class people, excellent food. Five stars isn't enough. Thank you!!!

I 'm always skeptical of Best of titles as Good Fellas was awarded this past year for the best pizza in Warrenton. Took me a bit to work up the courage to move away from Joe and Vinnies and Spitonys, but I 'm glad I tried them out. We had three large pizzas and a gluten-free pizza. All of them were solid, but my absolute favorite was the tandoori pizza. It was spectacular! It 's one of those pizzas that I 'll be craving again in a week.Update: We decided to try other dishes other than pizza and although the Philadelphia cheesesteak is okay, it 's by no means a Philadelphia cheesesteak. The meatball sub is about as good as Subway 's. In other words, not worth buying. Beyond pizza, I have to say that it 's a little bit disappointing.

Goodfellas in Warrenton is the place to go for delicious pizza and amazing wings. Our order was delivered promptly and without contact, and arrived quicker than we expected. The children's chicken nuggets and fries were both hot and tasty. Overall, I highly recommend Goodfellas for all your pizza cravings in Warrenton.