Balistreri's Italian-american

By far the best pizza that I have had anywhere in the US. I always stop here whenever I visit Wisconsin

I was quickly seated and had a really great server that was very polite and to the point. Also, he helped out on the menu. Which was big on the points! I'm not one to tip all that much, but my lady convinced me otherwise.

Upon entering the establishment, we were welcomed with a clean and pleasant atmosphere. We started with an order of some fantastic cheese sticks while we waited for our pizza to be made. While waiting, we had very little internet and cell phone signal and no guest wifi to log into to help us with our wait. That cost the establishment 1. After getting our order and eating a very delicious pizza, we felt like taking extra special care in tipping the waitress for a job well done. We then asked for a to go box for our pizza and cups for the remainder of our drinks. They boxed up our pizza for us but refused to let us take our drinks with us because it was free refills ....I never ever had that happen before. My wife 's drink was $4.00 and she only drank half. And I only had one refill that was half empty and wasn 't asking to top it off. So I 'm deducting 1 for that as well. The bills total was $52 not including our generous tip. I won 't let this stop us from going back, but they need to get some wifi for customers and throw that no free refill to go drink policy out the window! That really makes that establishment look greedy.......

Love this place. Just came back here for the first time in about a year for lunch, I missed it!

Great pizza, great eggplant fries, great service... this place is a classic Milwaukee pizza place! You can't go wrong ordering pizza here!!!