Old Fashioned Ice Cream - West Babylon

Delicious ice-cream and friendly staff. A must have if you're around this area.

My fave spot recently. Love the Central Perk ice cream.Also enjoyed some Cookie Monster ice cream.

Best ice cream on Long Island. They have so many flavors that I can’t really choose one.

Old fashioned Ice Cream is the best Ice Cream that i have ever had! I have been going to them for 50 years and they haven't changed!

We got an ice cream cake for a party. The pre-made ones are chocolate on bottom and vanilla on top with cookie crumbles in between. If you want different flavors you need to order in advance. They also have hard ice cream to scoop. And soft serve, about 4 flavors everyday. When we were there only one machine was ready. They're know for their Pineapple whip soft serve. Will go back for that.