Salty Tomato Pizzeria - West Haven

Nicole is an incredibly diligent worker and has done an excellent job. I will definitely be coming back!

I don't usually write reviews, but I want to prevent others from making the same mistake we did. My friend and I ordered a small sausage pizza, and we were disappointed to find that the crust was undercooked and soggy. We hoped they would fix it, but they returned it to us the same way. The picture shows how it looked after they gave it back. I wouldn't recommend this place.

The eggplant parmesan dinner is outstanding and one of the best meals we've ever had. For $12, you get a large portion, a side dish, and bread. We simply reheated the leftovers from last night, and they warmed up perfectly. We'll definitely be returning. Thank you!

There is a series of great pizzerias in the new haven area, this is a hidden gem. we like our pizza well made with a crispy crust and salty gets it right.

I usually don’t take time write reviews but I ordered 3 eggplant parm subs and a plain cheese pizza. The eggplant was raw on one of them, the bread was stale on all 3 and there was barely any cheese on any of them. I gave it one star because the pizza was ok. I know inflation is crazy but it doesn’t excuse making people pay for an inferior product by skimping on things and using old bread. If the inflation is hurting that bad perhaps only serve pizza or shut down until you can get it together to make edible food