Johnny's Pizzeria - West Orange

This evening I placed an order, and was disappointed with the order. I have going to Johnnys since 1992. My first order was the Italian cheese steak. I always ask for mozzarella cheese on it. That's my fav. But this evening I placed an order for a Marilyn Monroe and a whole Italian cheese steak with mozzarella cheese, when it was delivered I went to eat my cheese steak and it had American cheese. I was pissed. I called back and let the person that took my order that I asked for for mozzarella cheese and he told me that I didn't say mozzarella, I was not in the mood to go back a forth with him. He told me he was going to send me my sandwich. I said ok. I changed my mind because I thought maybe he would spit on it or something. I called back and told him never mind. I ate some of the sandwich and they surly don't make them good like they use too. Sad how the prices went up the quality went down.

I ordered 2 plain slices it was disgusting ? had kids working behind counter after playing in facility never will I go back

Great pizza, especially cheese with Hot Peppers! Highly-recommend!

Overall just a very blah pizza. Crust is cardboard and thin. Sauce and cheese were good though. It just didn’t hit the spot. Ordered a plain pie on 6/17/24. Delivered on time and hot. No problem there.

What the heck happened to this place, I haven't been there in a while so I went there for a ham, salami and cheese sub...I literally got one sluce of ham and the same for salamy and cheese I basically paid $8 for a HSC flavored piece of bread...not going back.