Pasquale's Pizza Subs - West Seneca

This is undoubtedly the best pizza around! It can be a bit challenging to place an order due to how busy the restaurant gets, but that just shows how popular it is. Their subs and pasta dinners are fantastic as well. I’ve never had a bad experience at Pasquale's.

Pizza, family, friends... a perfect Sunday afternoon. Pasquale's serves fantastic pizza—the dough is almost flawless, thick yet chewy enough to offer a satisfying bite with a little bit of char. If you’re a meat lover, definitely try the sausage and bacon; they’re my favorites and will leave you feeling completely satisfied. One of the great things about Pasquale's is the comfortable seating and family-friendly atmosphere; it's the perfect place to enjoy freshly baked pizza right out of the oven without needing to take out. I often gather with my nieces here. The experienced servers are engaging, answering questions and managing the high-energy moments with ease. It has become a family tradition for us. I truly hope Pasquale's remains around for many years to come.

Fortunately, Pasquale's consistently delivers exceptional pizza. The crust is neither too thick nor too thin, with just the right amount of chewiness. Many Buffalo pizzas suffer from overly thick, soft dough that feels flimsy. In contrast, Pasquale's sauce strikes the perfect balance—not too sweet—and the cheese is just right in quantity. The quality of the toppings is also excellent. You can enjoy every bite directly on the crust without feeling like you’re navigating a mound of dough separated from the cheese. All components of the pizza are well-balanced and consistent. We've also tried other Italian specialties that are expertly prepared, but the pizza steals the show. The restaurant is inviting and comfortable—not your typical pizzeria. It’s a lovely space where you’d feel comfortable bringing your grandmother or visitors from out of town. The service is outstanding, and the staff genuinely seem to care about their customers. Highly recommended!

Manicotti. It's always the same....amazingly hot yummy!! I'll never get tired! And their salads are the best....Love also their soups fresh bread. Wait for the weekends!! You know it's a great place to eat when the parking lot is full!! Never disappointed!

Always a great meal. I've eaten at Pasquale's on many occasions, ranging from 4pm on a weekday to a busy weekend evening. On the weekends, I have waited 20 minutes or so on average for a table (unfortunately they don't take reservations), but the food and service is always worth the wait. The portions are huge, and there's always lots of food left over to take home for lunch the next day. The prices are very reasonable, and the staff is always very knowledgable about their specials and the wine list. They have plenty of desserts to choose from on their dessert cart. Even on the busiest nights, the servers have been attentive and never dropped the ball.