Fella's Take Out - West Tisbury

I cannot recommend this restaurant. I tried the Italian dish and a burger, but the Italian was bland and overly soaked in dressing. The burger was a small, overcooked, and flavorless frozen patty, and for $11, I expected a side of fries to be included. Additionally, the staff was unfriendly. I won’t be returning.

CLAMBAKE GALORE!!! Fella's catered my brother's welcome dinner for his destination wedding, and we were looking for something casual, warm, local, and of course, delicious. Fella absolutely delivered! Even two months later, our guests are still raving about the best lobster they've ever tasted. The entire family was extremely accommodating, especially considering it was a last-minute wedding during COVID, where we had to change the time and location of the event several times. The entire team was organized and pleasant to work with. And we can't forget those homemade brownies—they were the perfect finish to an exquisite meal. It was truly the perfect evening. Thank you, Fella's!

The portions are extremely small. My Italian sub contained just one slice each of ham, salami, and cheese. My wife's turkey sandwich had only two slices of turkey. Charging $7 for a sandwich would have been excessive, but these were priced at $10.50 and $11.50. Save your money and skip the sandwiches here.

I cannot recommend this restaurant. I tried both the Italian dish and a burger. The Italian was disappointing and overly drenched in dressing. The burger was a small, overcooked, and bland pre-made patty. For $11, I expected a side of fries as well. Additionally, the staff was unfriendly. I won’t be returning.

During my week-long vacation on the island, I visited this restaurant every morning based on the recommendation of our landlord. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming; my daughter looked forward to giving them a high-five each morning. The coffee and pastries were delicious, and the location was perfect for where we were staying. I would definitely go back!