Bay Street Deli - Westerly

The ice cream is fantastic and the staff is very friendly. I work on Bay Street and always come here for lunch!

This sandwich shop is very simple and no-frills, located in a narrow space between more upscale bistros and shops. There is no atmosphere, but the food is good, the prices are great, and the service is excellent.

This is the best place in the area for lobster rolls. It's a fantastic family-owned spot for breakfast and lunch.

I was not even a customer at this deli, yet I had a negative experience. It was early in the morning with few people in Watch Hill, and I just wanted to sit at a table in front of the deli and enjoy my coffee. However, I was quickly scolded for not purchasing anything from the deli. This encounter alone discouraged me from ever becoming a customer of that establishment. The man in the deli could definitely benefit from being more polite to people.

First of all, I don't even like sandwiches but this place makes the best sandwiches ever, breakfast ones too (served until ~11am). I love ham but Bay Street Deli really made me realize it because in fact, they have the best ham you'll ever have in your life it's light, fluffy, and so flavorful. Check out the pic (the dunes) and you'll see what I mean but you'll have to taste it too. You can modify it to your liking like I do most of the time with the dunes (but only cos I have a sweeter tooth): white instead of marble bread, provolone instead of Swiss, and honey mustard instead of mustard. You seriously never had a ham or sandwich like this before. I also love getting breakfast sandwiches here (on a roll). In the morning, when you walk in, you hear the fresh egg shells cracking in the background it's a familiar sound like when you're at home and mom or dad make you breakfast, it's a great feeling followed by the far away sound of one egg at a time hitting the hot surface straight out of its shell, you can hear it bubble up and freshly fry away, and eventually you finally get the wrapped up sandwich with a swirl of breakfast goodness in the air. I look forward to every season when they reopen. They also have hot/iced coffee, with flavor options. I love their chocolate chip cookies too, freshly baked every day. Outdoor seating is available for a quick bite. They're sweet people, it's a family run business, and you can see their love of family in some wall decorations too. Now go get that sandwich!