Casey's - Ashley

After stopping yesterday for fuel for the third time since store opening, I noticed a few signs advertising their pizza, and in app ordering offering carside pickup of such. A little later I decided I'd give it a go. Ordered about 4, set time for 430 pickup. Arrived at 430, but unfortunately had to wait 15 minutes til someone walked out with my pizza. They didn't appear to be busy but being they are still new in town I'll give em a break on that this time. Hopefully thatdoesn't happen everytime. I'm not a huge fan of taco pizza to begin with, but visually it looked good and tasted alright. They don't include taco sauce so I added some myself which improved it. As for the Hawaiian, I was a littledisappointed in the first slice. Cutting of that pizza was a bit erratic and could be improved on. But my main problem was that It was very greasy, so much that the crust had gotten soggy from it, and everything just slipped off the crust.I expected greasy, but the first slice was just too much. Having said that, I grabbed a second slice after letting the pizza set for 20 minutes or so and it was much better. This morning I put a slice in the air fryer and crust had nosogginess left, and it was much better than that first slice I had tried. Taco pizza after putting in air fryer a day later was much better as well. So maybe I'll see if they can bake a little longer next time Overall not bad pizza as longas you don't get an extra greasy piece where the crust gets soggy. Would be better if bbq sauce was option for sauce instead of just marinara, taco sauce for the taco pizza and maybe more seasoning on crust itself, but still good pizza. Appordering and curbside pickup is a big plus. I'll give it another go in the future.

Stopped in the new Casey's in Ashley just needing a bite to eat quick. I decided to check the fresh pizza and hot food. Grabbed a bacon cheeseburger thinking it would just be some grub to fill me up in a hurry. As i walk up to the cashier to pay for my burger and bag of chips I grabbed, the woman who worked their accosted me about how i seemed disappointed about the selection/burger. I was a little confused considering i was solely looking for a quick and easy on the roadmeal. She assured me that she was just making sure i got what i wanted, and that if i needed anything made to order or added to the cheeseburger i had grabbed she would be more than willing to fix it up. I was taken aback by theconsideration to me as a customer from this caring worker. The bacon burger itself was actually really good for the price and what not. Thankful for the convenience of the new gas station and the great customer service from the employees atthe Casey's in Ashley Indiana!

Food is always decent at the least, and staff are always helpful. The location is extremely convenient for my daily commute. My only issue is that they claim this is a 24 hour location which is not true at all. Stopped this morning for some coffee and fuel and while there were 2 vehicles sitting in the front of the store all the inside lights were off and it was apparent they were not open. How can you be 24 hour if you're not open 24 hours? I'm assuming it's a staffing issue(same with the Casey's in Waterloo.

I work third shift at a factory right next to this location. I know they can 't be open 24 hours bc of staff I get that! I really do. But they are open at different times every day. Sometimes at 430. Was just there, and it was 605, they still were not open. I along with 2 other customers left bc we don 't know their hours anymore. They are pushing customers to the other gas station in town with this kind of stuff. When Casey 's opened here. The whole town was excited bc wedidn 't have to come to the marathon anymore, but here we are. Having no choice to return to the other gas station!!!!

I have never seen such a trashed out place in my entire life. Went there today and everything from the pizza ???? thing to the slushy machine is out of order. Who is running this brand new business?? Pretty sad when you have to go to the Ashley deli to get anything. I would fire everyone out there and start over. I wouldn't go back there if I was on empty and gas was $1,00. Good luck. I wouldn't give this place any stars ??