Timothy Jay Sweets - Millbury

I wish that I could give more than 5 stars! I am beyond impressed with both the DELICIOUS cupcakes and incredible service! I will most definitely be returning ?

Timothy made my day! I'd go back just for the healing vibes and positive conversation we had. It was hard to leave! The cupcake and cake pops were amazing and he even gave us candles for them since it was my birthday. My kids and I will definitely be going back for more whole hearted conversation and to experience new flavors! Following on Instagram for the joke of the day!

We made our daughter's first birthday party July 4th. Not realizing a lot of places were going to be closed July 3rd and 4th. My daughter loves unicorns and I had invisioned a unicorn cake for her. I stopped in to Timothy Jay Sweets hopefully he will be opened. He was amazing! He assured me I would get the unicorn cake for my little girl as well as a smash cake. He went over all the options and prices. Everyone loved it! Thank you so much time for helping this mom get the cake she wanted for her little girl

Tim has made TWO gorgeous cakes for me now- One fun gender reveal cake for my daughter in 2022 and recently made a custom safari themed cake for her 1st birthday. Cakes always taste amazing too!! We always snag a cupcake or cookie every time we swing through too. Highly recommend the funfetti flavor for the cakes! Thank you!

We ordered cupcakes. The icing tasted funny and hard. The cupcakes tasted very dry and hard. Everyone don't like it.